Smoker vs. Dehydrator for Jerky: Which Is Better?
Smoked jerky tastes better; dehydrated jerky is easier and more consistent. Here's how to choose, and why many jerky makers use both.
Both make great jerky. A smoker gives you real wood-smoke flavor. A dehydrator gives you even, predictable results with almost no babysitting. The right choice depends on what you already own and how much attention you want to give it.
The short answer
- Want the easiest, most consistent jerky? Use a dehydrator.
- Want the best flavor and already own a smoker? Use the smoker, or smoke first and finish in a dehydrator.
- Making jerky often or in big batches? Get a dehydrator. It's cheaper to run and doesn't tie up your smoker.
Side by side
| Dehydrator | Smoker | |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor | Clean; flavor comes from the marinade | Real wood smoke |
| Consistency | Very even, especially rear-fan models | Varies with fire and airflow |
| Effort | Set it and walk away | Needs fire or pellet management |
| Temperature control | Precise, low and steady | Hard to hold 160–180°F on many smokers |
| Weather | Indoors, any season | Outdoors, affected by cold and wind |
| Cost to start | About $50–$250 | You may already own one |
| Other uses | Fruit, herbs, dog treats | Everything else you smoke |
Smoker tips for jerky
Most smokers like to run at 225°F or higher, which is too hot for jerky: the outside cooks before the inside dries. Aim for 160–180°F.
- Pellet grills are the easiest smoker for jerky. Many have a low "smoke" setting.
- Electric smokers can usually hold low temperatures. Use chips, not chunks.
- Offsets and kettles are hard to keep that low. Use a small fire and plenty of vents open.
Lay strips directly on the grates or on wire racks, leave space between them for airflow, and use a mild-to-medium wood. Hickory and cherry are favorites. Thin strips take on smoke fast, so you don't need much.
The hybrid method
Many jerky makers combine the two:
- Smoke the marinated strips for 1–2 hours at 160–180°F for flavor.
- Move them to the dehydrator to finish drying evenly.
You get the smoke without spending all day nursing a fire.
Food safety either way
The USDA recommends heating jerky meat to 160°F (165°F for poultry) before or at the start of drying. With a dehydrator, a quick oven step handles it. With a smoker, run the first hour hot enough to bring the meat to temperature, and check with a thermometer.
Ready to start?
- See the best dehydrators for jerky
- Try our homemade beef jerky recipe
- Pick your wood with the wood pairing chart
Keep reading
The Best Fish for Smoking (and the Ones to Skip)
Which fish smoke best? Compare 18 fish by fat, flavor, best smoking style and wood, plus which lean fish to skip and how to smoke shellfish.
Beef Brisket Injection
A simple beef broth brisket injection that keeps the flat juicy, with how much to use per pound, where to inject and how to keep it safe.
Cajun Beef Jerky
Spicy Cajun beef jerky with a homemade Cajun rub, hot sauce and garlic, heated to the USDA 160°F before drying.